Jump to content

User talk:Chipmunkdavis

Add topic
From Wikimedia Commons, the free media repository
Latest comment: 4 days ago by Johannes Klarnus-Pettersen in topic Flag name
Welcome to Wikimedia Commons, Chipmunkdavis!
Afrikaans | Alemannisch | asturianu | azərbaycanca | Bahasa Banjar | català | čeština | Cymraeg | dansk | Deutsch | Deutsch (Sie-Form)‎ | English | español | Esperanto | euskara | estremeñu | français | Frysk | galego | hrvatski | Bahasa Indonesia | interlingua | Interlingue | íslenska | italiano | Kiswahili | Kurdî | Latina | lietuvių | magyar | Bahasa Melayu | Mirandés | Nederlands | norsk bokmål | occitan | Plattdüütsch | polski | português | português do Brasil | română | rumantsch | Scots | shqip | sicilianu | slovenčina | slovenščina | Basa Sunda | suomi | svenska | Tagalog | Türkçe | vèneto | Tiếng Việt | Zazaki | Ελληνικά | беларуская | беларуская (тарашкевіца)‎ | български | Ирон | македонски | нохчийн | русский | српски / srpski | тоҷикӣ | українська | ქართული | Հայերեն | नेपाली | भोजपुरी | मराठी | हिन्दी | অসমীয়া | বাংলা | தமிழ் | മലയാളം | සිංහල | ไทย | ລາວ | ၽႃႇသႃႇတႆး  | မြန်မာဘာသာ | 한국어 | 日本語 | 中文 | 中文(台灣)‎ | 中文(简体)‎ | 中文(繁體)‎ | 粵語 | עברית | اردو | العربية | تۆرکجه | سنڌي | فارسی | +/−

Welcome, Dear Filemover!

[edit]

العربية ∙ বাংলা ∙ Deutsch ∙ English ∙ español ∙ français ∙ 日本語 ∙ 한국어 ∙ кыргызча ∙ മലയാളം ∙ português ∙ русский ∙ Türkçe ∙ українська ∙ Tiếng Việt ∙ 中文(中国大陆) ∙ 中文(简体) ∙ 中文(繁體) ∙ 中文(臺灣) ∙ +/−


Hi Chipmunkdavis, you're now a filemover. When moving files please respect the following advice:

  • Use the CommonsDelinker link in the {{Rename}} template to order a bot to replace all occurrences of the old title with the new one. Or, if there was no rename-request, please use the Move & Replace-tab.
  • Please leave a redirect behind unless you have a valid reason not to do so. Other projects, including those using InstantCommons, might be using the file even though they don't show up in the global usage. Deleting the redirects would break their file references. Please see this section of the file rename guideline for more information.
  • Please know and follow the file rename guidelines.

Shaan SenguptaTalk 08:35, 6 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

Archiving this talk page

[edit]

Deutsch ∙ English ∙ español ∙ suomi ∙ français ∙ עברית ∙ magyar ∙ македонски ∙ português ∙ русский ∙ +/−


Hi! I see that this talk page is becoming quite long. Some old browsers may have problems editing pages approaching or longer than 32kb. Please archive this talk page in accordance with the guidelines laid out here. You can do this automatically with MiszaBot, and to quickly use a standard setup for MiszaBot, simply place {{subst:User:MiszaBot/usertalksetup}} at the top of your user talk page. Thank you.

Shaan SenguptaTalk 08:37, 6 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

Green Lantern

[edit]

Hi, I see you keep declining requests about Green Lantern pictures. I consider "Green Lantern" a very generic title, because there are hundreds of characters named "Green Lantern" (you can also check there), and calling them all "Green Lantern" could be confusing. Mikirito 07 (talk) 19:16, 12 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

There are lots of Green Lanterns, but that does not seem inherently ambiguous to the level of COM:FR as the names as uploaded identify the character per the knowledge of the uploader. It is unclear how a file mover is intended to verify the claim that the particular photo is a particular green lantern. CMD (talk) 00:06, 13 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
If you can't verify the claim, it doesn't mean it is untrue. Several file movers verified the same claim in the past and moved the images to the name of the specific Green Lantern, becuase naming every Green Lantern character "Green Lantern" is confusing, because they are different characters.
I gently ask you to wait untill other file movers check my renaming requests instead of just declining them. Mikirito 07 (talk) 13:01, 18 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
If you feel the proposals, which do far more than change Green Lantern names, meet COM:FR then please raise this in a central discussion. CMD (talk) 13:04, 18 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
Substituting an acronym with the actual name of the convention is 100% permitted by parameter 2 Mikirito 07 (talk) 13:07, 18 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
It is not, unless it is the "only piece of meaningful information". If you wish to change this a more central discussion would be needed. CMD (talk) 13:10, 18 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
Where can I start the discussion? Mikirito 07 (talk) 13:12, 18 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
A change to Commons:File renaming may need a discussion at COM:VP. CMD (talk) 13:18, 18 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
Thank you :) Mikirito 07 (talk) 13:20, 18 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

Flag name

[edit]

Hello. I noticed that my request to rename Flag of the Taleh-based Dervish State.svg was declined, partly because the existing filename may be intended to distinguish the Somali Dervish State from the Mahdist State.

Would "Flag of the Somali Dervish State.svg" be an acceptable alternative?

My concern with the current filename is that "Taleh-based" unnecessarily associates the Dervish State with one particular capital. As I explained in the file discussion, Said S. Samatar explicitly states in Oral Poetry and Somali Nationalism (p. 131) that the capital was moved from Illig (Eyl) to Taleh in late 1909. Contemporary sources, including The Royal Navy List (1917) and Shipbuilding and Shipping Record (1914), also describe Illig as the Mullah's "stronghold".

I believe "Somali Dervish State" would identify the historical entity more clearly, distinguish it from other Dervish states or movements, and thus avoid the potentially misleading geographical qualification.

Would this alternative satisfy the Commons file-renaming guidelines, particularly criterion 3, or would another criterion be more appropriate? Johannes Klarnus-Pettersen (talk) 23:50, 19 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

File renaming is done very conservatively, and criteria 3 is for situations such as "misspelled proper nouns, incorrect dates, and misidentified objects". Referring to a particular historical period does not meet this. CMD (talk) 23:57, 19 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
Thanks for the clarification. But my concern was primarily geographical rather than chronological, since “Taleh-based” identifies the state with one particular location despite its earlier capital at Illig. I understand that Commons applies its renaming criteria conservatively, but would “Flag of the Somali Dervish State.svg” qualify under another criterion, given that it identifies the historical entity without the geographical qualification? Johannes Klarnus-Pettersen (talk) 00:39, 20 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
It is not a change I would propose under COM:FR. CMD (talk) 00:44, 20 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
Understood. Thanks for the clarification. Johannes Klarnus-Pettersen (talk) 01:18, 20 October 2026 (UTC)Reply