User talk:Andy Dingley
Add topic
2007 2008 October, 2009 April, October, November, December, 2010 January, February, March, April, May, June, July, August, September, October, November, December, 2011 2011 January, 2011 February, 2011 March, 2011 May, 2011 June 2011 * 2012 * 2013 * 2014 * 2015 * 2016 * 2017 * 2018 * 2019 * 2020 * 2021 * 2022 * 2023 * 2024 * 2025 * 2026
Some changes this week
[edit]Hello Andy Dingley, you make some changes this week to vehicles in the Musée National de l'Automobile.
- Deletion request to Category:Lotus 33 (Musée National de l'Automobile) in the Musée National de l'Automobile (for pictures made in the museum) and changes in Category:Lotus 33 (Musée National de l'Automobile).
Please note that in the last category there are also pictures made at the Paris Motor show, definitely outside of the museum. According to the main categories which you added all pictures must show: 1960s Lotus automobiles in the Musée National de l'Automobile, 1960s automobiles in the Musée National de l'Automobile, 1963 automobiles in museums, Formula One cars in the Musée National de l'Automobile. It was a hard fight for me in the last years to correct all such mistakes made by User:Finoskov in these categories. - You created Category:1960s Lotus automobiles in the Musée National de l'Automobile without Category:Lotus automobiles in the Musée National de l'Automobile. Regards --Buch-t (talk) 16:36, 28 March 2026 (UTC)
- Thanks for starting this discussion. I'm receptive to any ideas you have for how best to do this.
- I see no point in having Category:Lotus automobiles in the Musée National de l'Automobile. All of their Lotuses are from the 1960s (AFAIK). I created one 1960 Lotus category for the museum, which is also in Category:Automobiles in the Musée National de l'Automobile and sorted as L for Lotus. In which case, creating the category for all Lotuses in all decades there would have no point, other than to add additional layers of navigation overhead.
- The only drawback to this is a truly trivial aesthetic one, of the wording used for the link from the all-cars page including the prefix '1960'. This is just one of the limitations that we have to work around with Mediawiki. It's a lot less of a drawback than the extra baggage of additional navigation layers which are adding nothing.
- There is a similar issue with Category:Violet-Bogey type A torpedo (M.N.A.) and Category:O.M. type 665 SS MM roadster (M.N.A.1322) 1931, where these are the only cars of that marque in the museum, thus I did not create the intermediate categories for them.
- I would like to see Category:Automobiles in the Musée National de l'Automobile expand so as to become an all-marques listing for the museum. Groups where there are multiples; single pages for single cars where there are not. That would have value to our readers. I found the structure very hard to follow before my recent visit because there was no complete list of marques. It is not useful to our readers to hide all the Audis from them (a marque with a long history under that name) and expect our readers to guess the decade they might be under! It's not too hard to guess that Lotuses were in the 1960s, but for Audi this would be guessing that a 1913 model was filed under 1924, for a maker far better known in the 1930s or 1980s. That's an unreasonable requirement.
- As to the Lotus 33 (and any general principles involved in that category) then it is (in the broad sense) the regular problem that we have to manage content which doesn't perfectly fit the structure we've built. In this case, the example of a museum exhibit that travels to other exhibitions.
- I see no point to concerning ourselves with this. The issue is simply trivial. Mediawiki categorisation is also (as always) navigational, not defining. It just doesn't have the capabilities to cover such situations in a useful manner. Attempts to do so (not unusual here) just make navigation unduly complex. If we had content of this car racing in the 1960s, then that would be different. Even if it came out to events like Goodwood and was photographed in action there, it would be worthwhile to separate them. But for two images of the car in Paris, looking identical to how it looks when also at rest in a different museum, there is no point in splitting.
- The category names are tautological anyway. If the content is so fluid that it can't simply be grouped under one, then why have the name of that venue in the category, implying that's where they are anyway? Are you advocating a training course being necessary for our readers before starting, lesson one being "The category with MNA in the name is the one that doesn't involve the MNA. You need to look instead at the one labelled twice as 'MNA in the MNA'." If we can't explain to our readers on sight that the category labelled 'MNA' is the one for images not in the MNA, then we've failed.
- This is particularly bad if, like here, Category:Lotus 33 (Musée National de l'Automobile) becomes inconsistent with Category:Lotus 18 in the Musée National de l'Automobile in that the category with the simple name [<marque> <MNA>] transforms into being the one that isn't at the MNA. That is a broken and ridiculous naming system. The only thing worse is the one where trivial and overlooked syntax such as '(...)' means the opposite of 'in the'. There is no way that that system would be any sense to anyone other than you, completely ignoring our customer here, the readership.
- As usual, our guiding principle should be that of defaults and refinement. For a museum collection, the default assumption will be that exhibits are in that museum. We make that the basic behaviour for the parent category (the top level for any Lotus 33 content within this collection). The exceptions to this then become the exceptions. If we have coverage of a museum collection car in its racing heyday, then we put those in a subcategory beneath. Likewise if one makes a loan trip elsewhere. But the starting point of this tree, for all exhibits equally, should be that its content of this car in this museum. If we distinguish anything within that, we make those the exception and leave the default in place.
- I am open to any discussion of these issues, but I am unconvinced by your points here. Andy Dingley (talk) 17:59, 28 March 2026 (UTC)
- You created Category:1960s Lotus automobiles in the Musée National de l'Automobile with the main Category:Lotus automobiles in the Musée National de l'Automobile, but this category does not exist. It is a red category. Where is the sense to use red categories? You can remove the red category and this problem is solved for me.
- When I look at your last edits then I find more examples where you use red categories without creating them: Category:Tower blocks in Somerset, Category:Telephone exchanges in Gloucestershire, Category:Methodist Chapels in Devon, Category:Lock-up garages in England. I am wondering. But this categories are not of interest for me.
- Please look at Category talk:Musée National de l'Automobile. Last year, when there was the disput with User:Finoskov, I started to write my thinkings about the category system for this museum. He did not answer. Nobody answered. I did some changes but I did not change the wholly system. Now, 14 months later, it would be necessary for me to think from the beginning again.
- Now to the bigger problem: pictures in museum and pictures made elsewhere.
- To categorize images in categories where they are not right according to the category name or category structure, is deceptive. (In German de:Täuschung, I hope that en:Deception/deceptive is the right translation.)
- When we have a category which is in main categories like „in the Musee Automobile“ or „in museums“ then I cannot accept pictures made elsewhere. We have to find a way to prevent incorrect category assignments.
- I will be back next weekend. --Buch-t (talk) 17:00, 29 March 2026 (UTC)
- There was no answer in the last weeks. --Buch-t (talk) 10:04, 31 May 2026 (UTC)
- Again no answer in the last weeks. Not here and not at Questions to the museum in Mulhouse. I will try to visit the museum next month. At the website there is a notice of QR codes. Was it already introduced in March? --Buch-t (talk) 16:25, 2 August 2026 (UTC)
- Sorry, but I can't see what you want from me here? Andy Dingley (talk) 18:39, 2 August 2026 (UTC)
- Again no answer in the last weeks. Not here and not at Questions to the museum in Mulhouse. I will try to visit the museum next month. At the website there is a notice of QR codes. Was it already introduced in March? --Buch-t (talk) 16:25, 2 August 2026 (UTC)
- I wrote the link to the message about QR codes in the museum.
- Questions: Did you see any QR codes in the museum that provide more details about the specific car?
- You made pictures of vehicles. Only selected vehicles or all vehicles?
- Did you also make pictures of the descriptions? Selected or all vehicles? --Buch-t (talk) 06:18, 3 October 2026 (UTC)
- The QR codes are new since I was there. I didn't see any on the info boards - I thought at the time that this would have been a useful feature to add. I did photograph some of the info boards, as the easiest notebook for identifying the other photos. However I can't upload them here, as they're covered by copyright in France. Andy Dingley (talk) 12:47, 4 October 2026 (UTC)
Please revert your edits to mine of this morning!
[edit]You reversed my edit of this morning. That does not make me happy. The problem is: in Category:Association football in the Netherlands is Category:Football photography in the Netherlands a subcategory, AND there are 16(!) subcategories for Football photography by [name photographer], which should be in Category:Football photography in the Netherlands as well. I solved that problem. AND for Erich Koch and Jan Voets are subcategories by years (so overcategorisation), which I solved as well. So please revert your edits to mine of this morning again. Now it is a mess. JopkeB (talk) 15:20, 20 August 2026 (UTC)
- Exactly the same problem in Category:Cycling photography by Henk Lindeboom.
- And how can Category:Sports in the Netherlands as a parent of Category:Sports photography by Henk Lindeboom be redundant? I do not see it as a parent of Category:Photographs by Henk Lindeboom.
--JopkeB (talk) 15:26, 20 August 2026 (UTC)
- You made a bunch of random edits (not even consistent) and broke a bunch of stuff. Now you're (yet again) playing Mr Angry and blaming other people for it.
- Swapped link targets from soccer to football (i.e. American football, and all the other sportball variants in the broad sense)
- Swapped title texts to "Football photography photography"
- Swapped link targets to en:WP to an article on "football photography" that doesn't exist, and is unlikely to ever exist.
- Some of them had subcategories by year. This is because some of those had hundreds of images in each year, too many to throw into one pile. As sport is so strongly seasonal, subcategorizing by year is entirely reasonable. Do not remove it.
- Some time back you demanded that cycling links here point to 'cycling (sport)' rather than recreational 'cycling'. I did this for you. You now reverted it.
- You made this mess, then walked away. I do not support OWN over content areas, but if you're going to make big blanket changes, then either get it right, or expect to be reverted.
- This is a collaborative project. You seem to have some problem working under such a system. Maybe it's unfair to expect you to continue doing so.
- These categories have been largely stable and sorted for some years. There are a great many of them, there are thousands of images under them. Because there are so many of them, there's a template to assist with this. I know you don't like templates and want rid of them, but you're not the one having to deal with the categorization of this huge number of images. It's not going to happen (certainly not cleanly or consistently) otherwise.
- Since these were first set up you've introduced a new category Category:Football photography in the Netherlands. Which is fine. If you'd mentioned this, it could already have been integrated cleanly and without needing to make any changes to the categories - the benefit of using a centralised template. But instead you'd prefer to hack it around, make a mess, and then act all hurt when someone cleans up after you? Andy Dingley (talk) 19:36, 20 August 2026 (UTC)
- Please, assume good faith. I made the changes with good intentions. Thanks for adjusting the template. But there are still some problems:
- The subcategories for Erich Koch and Jan Voets by year still have been overcategorized. For Erich Koch they show up in Football photography by Eric Koch, which has Category:Football photography in the Netherlands as a parent as well as in Category:Football photography in the Netherlands itself. Same vor Jan Voets. Can you solve that as well?
- The problem has not been solved for Category:Cycling photography by Henk Lindeboom. This subcategory should be in Cycling photography in the Netherlands by photographer, but is in Category:Cycling (sport) in the Netherlands. Can that be solved as well?
- I still miss a second parent category for Category:Sports photography by Henk Lindeboom. It should at least have something like Category:Sports photography for the sports part in the category name.
- JopkeB (talk) 06:27, 21 August 2026 (UTC)
- Please, assume good faith. I made the changes with good intentions. Thanks for adjusting the template. But there are still some problems:
Arc discharge
[edit]Most of these lamps are based on arc discharge. Fluorescent lamps are low-pressure arc lamps, as opposed to neon lamps that are glow-discharge lamps. Mercury-vapor light bulbs, metal halide lamps and sodium lamps are high-pressure arc lamps. Tucvbif (talk) 18:58, 1 September 2026 (UTC)
- Not in English language electrical engineering they're not. Maybe in Russian. There are several forms of discharge, arcs are one but there's still a big difference between a xenon or carbon arc and a fluorescent tube. Even between a xenon and a sodium lamp. We could make some pedantic case that 'sodium lamps make use of an arc' (for high pressure they even use a xenon arc) and we'd be right on some descriptive level of physics, but this doesn't change the name that's used for them. Misapplying a name 'because the name everyone uses is wrong' isn't helpful.
- Two issues in particular.
- Common usage does not call fluorescent lamps 'arc lamps'. We call them 'discharge lamps' for a reason.
- Placing Category:Fluorescent lamps as a subcategory of Category:Arc lamps isn't just unhelpful like this, it's wrong. There is a disjoint between the category meanings and the subtle semantic arguments we might make above. What's in Category:Arc lamps aren't just 'any type of lamp using an arc, that we might possibly stretch the case for them involving an arc at some extent', it's more specific and narrow than that: it's for the lamps (and only the lamps) that we regard as {arc, ~discharge} lamps. That group excludes those here, even if they are still discharge lamps.
- Andy Dingley (talk) 19:56, 1 September 2026 (UTC)
- > Maybe in Russian
- Yes, in Russian most of these lamps are called arc lamps. And fluorescent lamps are called arc lamps in literature. Because these types of lamps are using the arc discharge. It's physics. Yes, not all gas-discharge lamps are arc lamps, for example category:Cold cathode fluorescent lamps aren't.
- And Wikimedia Commons is a multilingual project, so category should based on the nature of the subject. These lamps are still arc lamps, despite you calling it that way in English or not. Tucvbif (talk) 17:47, 6 September 2026 (UTC)
A barnstar for you!
[edit]| The Tireless Contributor Barnstar | |
| Despite occasional, and natural, disagreements, here is a barnstar recognizing the work you have been doing on Commons for years! Yacàwotçã (talk) 00:09, 29 September 2026 (UTC) |
- Thankyou Andy Dingley (talk) 09:36, 29 September 2026 (UTC)
sorry
[edit]"Andy Dingley hinterließ eine Nachricht auf deiner Diskussionsseite in „Cat sort orders“. Please don't remove category sort orders like this." I had seen such a sort order like this in other categories and thought it was a good idea. I will not do like this again, regards Joachim Lutz (talk) 18:17, 2 October 2026 (UTC)
- Sorry, this was my premature over-reaction. I misinterpreted what you were trying to do.
- I would have done much the same, except I'd have used a space rather than a '0' and I'd have re-stated the country name,
... | Austria]]. This has the same useful effect of grouping the 'country' entries together at the start, but it avoids having a weird '0' appear out of nowhere. Also re-stating it is useful, because it makes the sorting clearer and more robust. Even though these groups all had exactly the same name format (so they'd sort correctly, even though the country name is at the end), that's not always guaranteed. - My mistake was to confuse you with another recent editor who has the definitely wrong idea of removing cat sort keys and writing in a series of numeric values for each one. This just doesn't work.
- My apologies Andy Dingley (talk) 18:34, 2 October 2026 (UTC)
Maybe I am overreacting
[edit]I may be overreacting. Before I say anything, I would like to acknowledge that you are a longtime editor and also seem to be a highly productive and helpful editor. I appreciate your work as an editor.
Even regarding this matter, you seem quite courteous at Commons:Deletion requests/File:Neutral Lead And Neutral Trail Grip in Golf.jpg.
That being said, you have made some comments recently that I felt were not assuming the best of faith and personal. For example, you stated in at Commons:Deletion requests/File:Commonsjak Soyjak Trace Comparison.png, that my actions were being a "bludgeon discussion."
. You also said at Commons:Deletion requests/File:Aux cuisines du chateau, une corne dabondance IA Dall e Bing 18 nov 2023 Lamiot 02.png that my conduct was "This is now passing from a bad nomination and DR to being bad and disruptive editing in general."
I pinged you in that deletion request and asked you to explain how I have been a disruptive editor, as I did take that remark rather personally. Maybe I am just being a little sensitive, and your actions are perfectly reasonable.
However, I also noticed that at Commons:Deletion requests/File:AI Clockpunk comic.jpg, a deletion request that I stated, you made a comment about another user (@Dronebogus). I might be mistaken but it might be inferred that you are following a pattern of w:wp:hounding.
As I stated above I respect you as an editor, however, it seems at times you been getting a little personal with your comments. Issac I Navarro (talk) 18:13, 8 October 2026 (UTC)
- You may infer my opinion of some editors by how I treat them in discussions. Some editors here hold positions that are so biased on particular issues that their opinions and responses to each issue are now entirely predictable in advance, not based on any policy, nor on any objective assessment of a particular situation. This is not a constructive behaviour and it attracts little respect, certainly not from me.
- It is not hounding to call every bad edit a bad edit. If you don't want boilerplate responses to be called out as such, don't post long series of identical rubberstamp DRs without the slightest basis on each image, just an anti-AI comment that still doesn't match agreed policy here.
- If you want a blanket ban on AI, you're both going to have to change policy here first, not just act as if that already is the policy. Andy Dingley (talk) 18:37, 8 October 2026 (UTC)
- I actually don't completely hate ai. I have very complicated feeling about Ai. And there may be at times when Ai is acceptable.
- The Soyjak Trace Comparison, was not about Ai though. It was about unused artwork that I nominated per scope.
- If you have no patience for some editors that is fair. I can understand that, I edit a bit in English WikiProject Schools, and there is a lot of vandalism from unregistered users whom just edit and add puffery. However as annoying as that is. The vast majority are just trying their best. I try and never w:WP:BITE, the newer editor and assume good faith with all.
- You can have opinions, about me or others based on our edit history. And in some aspects that may be fair. But, when those opinions enter discussions about the quality of content, over the editor. It just mucks up any constructive collaboration.
- I am not only targeting Ai generated images. Here are some others I have nominated:
- Commons:Deletion requests/File:A Villager’s Day Out.jpg
- Commons:Deletion requests/File:Personal picture1.jpg
- Commons:Deletion requests/File:Personal photo for user page.jpg
- Commons:Deletion requests/File:0punkt.png
- Commons:Deletion requests/File:1 (1 of 1).jpg
- Commons:Deletion requests/File:Aasstudioaslampic.jpg
- Commons:Deletion requests/File:BOBLE DANCER (27764).jpg
- Commons:Deletion requests/File:Zaid Zarar.jpg
- Commons:Deletion requests/File:AliceLim.jpg
- Commons:Deletion requests/File:Golf 2013-05-12 13-55.jpg
- Commons:Deletion requests/File:Hanks.png
- Commons:Deletion requests/File:Lego swastika.jpg
- Among many more, as you can see, I don't only target Ai images. Issac I Navarro (talk) 19:46, 8 October 2026 (UTC)
"It was about unused artwork"
- Why do you always have to argue that things are 'unused'? That is absolutely irrelevant to Commons policy.
- Yet (and I've been here quite a while) it keeps coming back, and being used by some editors as a reason for deletion. This is wrong. Persisting in relying on it just discredits your nominations. Andy Dingley (talk) 19:52, 8 October 2026 (UTC)
- If a file is COM:INUSE, it makes it absolutely in COM:SCOPE.
- However, I often include "unused" not as a core principle for deletion but more as context when looking back at the archives. If that is unclear and it seems like I am just trying to delete images that are not not being used. Then I should probably rephrase that sentence. Yet, many of the closing admin seemed to understood what I have meant as all those examples above have ended in deletion. If a image has no realistic COM:EDUSE and falls outside of scope it should be deleted. COM:HOST. Issac I Navarro (talk) 20:27, 8 October 2026 (UTC)
It is not hounding to call every bad edit a bad edit
it is hounding to follow the same user around and treat them like they’re an idiot for making edits you consider bad, mixed with obvious ad hominem attacks.I'm really finding it hard to see the difference between 'Porn Dronebogus likes' and 'Porn that Dronebogus is vehemently against
on a vandalism noticeboard.These are garbage nominations […] part of such an obvious personal crusade
on my talk page, followed up by a user report literally titled ”Dronebogus and another dogmatic crusade against all AI images”.Maybe dronebogus wants to replace everything on Commons with blurry porn
at Commons:Deletion requests/File:Kidvelo Rookie 12 Balance Bike.png.This is far from 'AI fetish slop'. Nor is that even a deletion policy here, as Dronebogus well knows, as he's uploaded plenty of it himself.
at Commons:Deletion requests/File:Sopakaranavrishchikasana.png.Ah yes, Dronebogus being 'reasonable' and 'statesmanlike'
at Commons:Deletion requests/File:AI Clockpunk comic.jpg.When citing policy to support an argument, it's good to check beforehand that it does support that viewpoint
andyou have more [“frivolous crap”] on your own pages than any other editor here!
at Commons:Deletion requests/File:Vigilant Cosmic Penguin Core Contest Championship Belt.png. An extremely backhanded compliment at Commons:Deletion requests/File:Bupuro-chan.png:the uploader does have some useful familiarity with obscure Japanese subcultures […] Not always SFW ones
. Not to mentionignorant Yanks trying to delete Donald Campbell […] Dronebogus has had years to create a better impression of their opinions, and they still haven't managed it.
three years ago at Enwiki. I am still waiting on an apology for that. Dronebogus (talk) 04:38, 10 October 2026 (UTC)- @Andy Dingley and @Dronebogus, I am quite sorry if I may have struck a nerve. I didn't wish to cause drama and open old wounds. It seems the two of you have a long history. I often tend to keep to myself, edit what comes to mind, and, for the most part, not keep up with individual users. I am not a big fan of drama. Perhaps the two of you should take this to COM:AN/U. To find some common ground, we are all adults who share a passion for Wikipedia. I am sure we can work something out so that we can continue to be constructive with one another when our editing paths cross, and we can collaborate in peace.
- Andy Dingley, as I was the one who brought this matter up, I wanted to address what you said to me and how it seems like a pattern of behavior. It did make me feel a little attacked. Then again, perhaps I am overreacting, but after looking at the more context how you deal with others. I get the impression that you tend to make assumptions. Issac I Navarro (talk) 05:07, 10 October 2026 (UTC)
- If you don't want your DR nominations criticised, then write better DRs. Don't rubberstamp the same "Delete all AI just because it's AI" across all of them. Don't tack on irrelevancies like COM:PERSONAL or 'unused' to them, because these have no relevance and are merely being used to bludgeon discussions by bulking out the nominations.
- Dronebogus, the 'ignorant yank' comment was never aimed at you (I don't know where you're from), but rather at one of the US car editors (I forget the name) who kept trying repeatedly to remove Bluebird CN7 from the land speed record. But your attempt to delete all of the Bluebird vehicles attracted much the same opinion. Andy Dingley (talk) 10:12, 10 October 2026 (UTC)
- @Andy Dingley, I define some Ai content as "Artwork without obvious educational value, including non-educational artwork uploaded to showcase the artist's skills" - COM:PERSONAL. Additionally there is COM:NOTUSED.
- Andy Dingley as I have expressed, you seem to be a highly productive and helpful editor. And I do deeply appreciate the service that you do. However, all I ask is that if you can possibly try and COM:AVOIDYOU. I do welcome criticism of the content. I don't of the editor.
- Furthermore, I'm not only going after Ai generated media. However, for the Ai files that I do happen nominate; COM:F10 was suggested to me in Commons:Deletion requests/File:The Watercolor Forest.jpg by @Belbury. I followed up with saying: "For whatever reason, it seems that some get touchy with AI images. Additionally, I don't want the idea to manifest that I am trying to remove all old and unused images in a stealthy way." I hope you can see that I'm doing my best to not do any
"disruptive editing in general"
. Issac I Navarro (talk) 16:42, 10 October 2026 (UTC) - Wow, the racist remark wasn’t aimed at me, but rather someone else. The fact that you don’t see the problem with using nationality/ethnicity as an insult in the first place (you’ve done the same thing with Russians), and you were still personally attacked me then and now, is a problem. Your remarks are not “this is a bad DR and here is why”, they are “why does this user make such horrible DRs” at best and at worst are “lol you upload weird porn” and the aforementioned anti-American/anti-Russian remarks. You also are not an infallible expert on DRs— all of the yoga DRs you acted absolutely certain were in scope were deleted. Being right isn’t enough, and frequently you are not even right. Dronebogus (talk) 01:18, 11 October 2026 (UTC)
- @Dronebogus and @Andy Dingley, I once again highly recommend making a post at COM:AN/U.
- I have a great deal of respect for both of you as editors, as you have both been members of this project far longer than I have. And are both highly knowledgeable editors. Furthermore, Andy Dingley, while I do feel you have made multiple personal attacks against my conduct as an editor, I might just be overreacting. That may not have been your intention.
- I really don't want to pick sides, as I don't know either of you or your history. However, I just got to say, the issues the two of you seem to be having come across as immature. Issac I Navarro (talk) 01:30, 11 October 2026 (UTC)