Jump to content

Commons:Village pump/Copyright

Add topic
From Wikimedia Commons, the free media repository
Latest comment: 1 hour ago by JWilz12345 in topic File:대구광역시 Daegu.jpg

Shortcuts: COM:VP/C • COM:VPC

Welcome to the Village pump copyright section

This Wikimedia Commons page is used for general discussions relating to copyright and license issues, and for discussions relating to specific files' copyright issues. Discussions relating to specific copyright policies should take place on the talk page of the policy, but may be advertised here. Recent sections with no replies for 7 days and sections tagged with {{section resolved|1=~~~~}} may be archived; for old discussions, see the archives.

Please note
  1. One of Wikimedia Commons' basic principles is: "Only free content is allowed." Please do not ask why unfree material is not allowed at Wikimedia Commons or suggest that allowing it would be a good thing.
  2. Have you read the FAQ?
  3. Any answers you receive here are not legal advice and the responder cannot be held liable for them. If you have legal questions, we can try to help but our answers cannot replace those of a qualified professional (i.e. a lawyer).
  4. Your question will be answered here; please check back regularly. Please do not leave your email address or other contact information, as this page is widely visible across the Internet and you are liable to receive spam.
  5. Please do not make deletion requests here – instead, use the relevant process for it.

SpBot archives all sections tagged with {{Section resolved|1=~~~~}} after 1 day and sections whose most recent comment is older than 7 days.
[edit]
    • Subject: Copyright verification needed – Tchaikovsky Piano Concerto No. 1 (CC0 file / Sony Music Content ID claim)**

Hello Wikimedia Commons community,

I would like to request assistance in verifying the copyright status of the following audio file:

https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Tchaikovsky,_Concerto_No.1_in_B-flat_minor_Op.23,_I._Allegro.ogg

The file is marked as available under the CC0 1.0 Universal Public Domain Dedication and lists Musopen as its source.

However, the recording does not clearly identify its performers or original recording date.

I used a 3-minute and 38-second excerpt in a YouTube test upload, and YouTube Content ID identified the audio as copyrighted material claimed by Sony Music Entertainment (SME), associated with RCA Red Seal.

I would appreciate assistance with the following questions:

1. Is the CC0 1.0 designation for this specific recording supported by verifiable evidence? 2. Is there documentation identifying the pianist, orchestra, conductor, and recording date? 3. Has this file previously been reviewed for possible copyright issues? 4. Could this recording be identical to a commercially copyrighted RCA Red Seal recording? 5. Should the file's copyright status be reviewed if the licensing information cannot be verified?

I am not claiming that the YouTube Content ID match proves copyright infringement. I would simply like to establish whether the recording can legally be reused in a monetized classical music video.

Thank you very much for your assistance. ~2026-54759-18 (talk) 00:51, 13 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

If you have reviewed the file description page, I'm afraid you probably know as much as anyone here. While it wouldn't be terribly surprising for such a company to claim copyright on something it doesn't own, it also wouldn't be unusual for a file hosted on Commons to not be as free as the uploader claimed or believed. It appears that the Musopen page for the composition is now here, with two recordings of the Allegro that are claimed to be public domain. Both of those are credited to the European Archive Foundation, later known as the Internet Memory Foundation. (You would need a better ear than mine to say if either of those are actually the same recording as this one.) Unfortunately, that Foundation is no longer around to answer any questions about the recording's provenance. There has been at least one prior deletion of similar files from the same source, on the basis that there was insufficient evidence that they were public domain in the US under the CLASSICS Act of 2018. It seems to me that the same may be the case for this file, and that it has simply escaped the community's attention until now. -- Visviva (talk) 02:41, 13 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
Correction: based on the archived version of the credited Musopen page, which identifies the work as "Concerto Per Pianoforte E Orche N.1 - in si bemolle minore Op.23", it seems likely that the correct current link is this one instead. However, that page also credits the European Archive Foundation, and I think the same concerns would likely apply. -- Visviva (talk) 02:53, 13 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
For what it's worth: YouTube's content ID is notorious for misidentifying classical music as a different recording of the same piece. I wouldn't consider its report definitive. Omphalographer (talk) 03:01, 13 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
I second that comment. Performers of classical music often struggle with YouTube's content ID system, as it can't reliably differentiate between performances, and false positives are extremely common. For the case at hand, it could be helpful to listen to both recordings, if possible. Maybe it's possible to listen to the copyrighted RCA Red Seal recording somewhere online, and then you could compare it to the Musopen recording to find out whether it's really the same recording... Gestumblindi (talk) 20:15, 13 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
Using a spectrum visualizer such as Spek may also help compare. Arlo James Barnes 05:04, 21 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
I had a similar claim a few years ago. I objected and had success. The Content ID system is trash, as fakes can claim copyright they don't own. --PantheraLeo1359531 😺 (talk) 06:49, 21 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
I wouldn't even assume bad faith when it comes to classical music. Such a system, apparently, jusn't isn't really made for the case of the same piece performed by different artists. And so it mixes up performances that are copyrighted (that is, actually, protected by performers' / recording rights, as the recorded work itself is often in the public domain) and freely licensed ones. Gestumblindi (talk) 20:33, 22 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

License change for David Revoy's Pepper and Carrot and other works

[edit]

License update: AI derivation prohibited on all my art, lore, stories, and comics.

We have many hundreds of works here by this artist (Category:David Revoy). Now he has announced new terms to restrict AI-generated derivative works of his art, and intends to apply those terms retroactively. What's troublesome is that he's clearly writing in his second language and not in legally rigorous terms. He seems to link this new restriction to his moral rights under French law, which we generally consider COM:NCR. But he also talks about the inadequacy of the existing set of Creative Commons license options, and frames his new terms as a "DIY" addon, which would clearly implicate economic rights. My opinion is:

  1. All CC-licensed works published by Mr. Revoy prior to October 8, 2026 are good here. The license at the time of publication allowed for AI-generated derivative works, and it is irrevocable.
  2. Works published since that date should not be hosted here, since the artist clearly intends to restrict, through copyright law, the preparation of certain kinds of derivative works.

@Deevad: would appreciate any input or clarification you have to offer.

Phillipedison1891 (talk) 04:35, 14 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

Creative Commons licenses are irrevocable, even partially, so I agree with you that Wikimedia Commons may no longer allow images of Revoy's artworks published after his announcement in 8 October 2026. The CC BY 4.0 license itself practically waives moral rights to the maximum extent permissible by law, so I struggle to see how Revoy can now assert them here.
If Revoy is reading this, I would recommend that he:
  1. Consider using one of the "Human Commons" licenses (not created by Creative Commons organization), which are explicitly designed for permitting human reuse while prohibiting AI reuse. Such licensed images would still not be permitted on Commons, but it's a better solution to his particular issue than attempting a "DIY" edit to the irrevocable CC license.
  2. If possible, state on his website that the new terms only apply for content published since 8 October 2026, and drop any retroactive modifications to the CC BY 4.0 license.
– Howardcorn33 (💬) 05:45, 14 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
In any case, due to the unique copyright situation, a Commons editor should create a specific copyright template for Revoy's works akin to {{President.gov.ua}}. – Howardcorn33 (💬) 17:53, 14 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
{{Don Ramey Logan credits}} is another example that mentions non-copyright concerns. Arlo James Barnes 19:41, 18 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
Author here. First, thank you Arlo James Barnes for pointing me on the Fediverse this thread here. Second, I updated the statement in the article after the request of Howardcorn33, to clarify about that I'm not making any illusion or wish about a retroactive decision. The artworks and media hosted on Commons are safe. Also thank you for pointing the [humanscommons.org], I'll study that carefully, it might looks and communicate better than my DIY for future artworks. I hope it clarifies everything. David (Deevad) Revoy 22:03, 18 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
Thank you for considering my suggestions. I hope you will find the license that is most appropriate for your purposes. – Howardcorn33 (💬) 18:47, 19 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
Opening an issue on his Gitlab repo for the comics may help bring this thread to his attention (and to his collaborators, who contribute text to the translated versions). I would but as usual 2FA got in the way. But I sent him a note via Mastodon which he has now seen. I see that he ruled out involving a lawyer on expense grounds. Maybe-relevant posts from Creative Commons: 1, 2, 3 — Arlo James Barnes 18:14, 18 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
  • He's welcome to change the licence he offers to anything he wishes. He will though lose the convenience of using a licence that's widely known and understood.
He can't change the licence for any previous offers of that content, such as those we've already hosted here. They can remain here under that previous licence.
We shouldn't add any new content, as the new licence is no longer free to our strict requirements. Nor should we upload any new content and claim the old licence for it (Commons has done this before, but shouldn't.) Andy Dingley (talk) 19:01, 18 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
@Andy Dingley: When you say "new" content - are you merely saying we shouldn't upload anything published on or after 2026-10-08? Or are you saying that no further Pepper and Carrot content should be uploaded to Commons since the artist has gone back and tagged all the old stuff with his "AI derivation prohibited" terms? I mean, if we want to be really kosher, we can get it from an archive copy that doesn't have that notation. But I don't think that's necessary as long as they're the same files, since the CC license is attached to the work, not the specific copy available on the website, and it is irrevocable. Obviously IANAL though. Phillipedison1891 (talk) 08:04, 22 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
Obviously we can keep anything that was here under the original licence, before the change.
We can't use anything first published after this change.
Stuff inbetween is less clear. We have to be certain that it was published under the original licence, and that there's a credible publishing chain for its history before it reached Commons. A reliable archive site would do this.
What we shouldn't do (yet we have done in the past) is to grab at any content we don't yet have, and claim that it must have been published under the original licence. Even though we have didn't access a copy with that licence on it. Andy Dingley (talk) 11:47, 22 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
At Howardcorn33's suggestion, I have created Template:David Revoy AI notice. I would appreciate any feedback on the wording, especially from Deevad. Phillipedison1891 (talk) 10:01, 22 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

Usage of media from Brazilian federal institutions

[edit]

Good day,

Currently on Commons, only the image archive of the Brazilian Chamber of Deputies has a template stating that its files are licensed as CC-BY ( {{Banco de imagens da Câmara dos Deputados}} ). However, per the Chamber website, both the audio files and video broadcasts of 'legislative activities' are also licensed under CC-BY 4.0. It seems that other content produced by TV Câmara and Rádio Câmara has a more restrictive licence, however. Thus, expanding the template currently in use or creating another one encompassing the other types of content made by the Chamber would be useful.

I'm also here to request a clarification about the usage of videos by the Brazilian Supreme Court. Their website says that the reproduction of their YouTube content is authorized; I'm not sure if this excludes modification and thus is unable to be uploaded on Commons.

Thank you. — Inter-rede✉•🖉•📷︎ 12:38, 16 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

Having templates for the legislative audio and video seems like a good idea to me, especially if we actually have such media.
As to the STF videos, in my opinion permission for "reproduction" alone does not meet COM:L. See in particular Article 29 of the copyright law, which distinguishes reprodução from nine other types of utilização that require the author's permission, such as editing, translating, and using in other works. -- Visviva (talk) 02:49, 21 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
Thanks for the answer. I've uploaded some audio files from the Chamber of Deputies in the category Speeches in the Chamber of Deputies of Brazil. — Inter-rede✉•🖉•📷︎ 11:11, 21 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

Glowing-pickle-elfi-von-fliegenpilz.png

[edit]

Something like 9 years ago, I uploaded File:Glowing-pickle-elfi-von-fliegenpilz.png. I can't say I remember any of the details, but I did note that the original was under CC-BY-3.0. Unfortunately, the original seems to have been taken down, archive.org doesn't have any good copies of it, and there is a claim that this is a copyvio. Other than stating that I understand what a CC license is and I wouldn't have said it was released with that if the original didn't say it, I don't really have any way to prove that it is so. How should I proceed? RoySmith (talk) 01:09, 17 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

Good news: there is an archived copy of the video page at https://web.archive.org/web/20140313075036/https://vimeo.com/55172068
Bad news: it's not clear that the video was actually licensed as CC. The music was attributed as CC-BY content, but that doesn't say anything about the video.
Omphalographer (talk) 02:22, 17 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
I wonder if contacting the original author is possible. I went to the website but it is.. at first glace... unhelpful. https://elfivonfliegenpilz.org/ The Tduk (talk) 15:41, 17 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

Interpretation of PD-GermanGov

[edit]

Does {{PD-GermanGov}} assert that any and all works created by the German government are in the public domain? I interpreted it as only including legal texts (legislation, decrees, ordinances, court rulings, etc.), not photographs or artworks. The text of the template makes no mention of non-textual items. Nevertheless, two deletion discussions for File:German antisemitic poster, 1942.jpg have concluded that PD-GermanGov does apply for an image of a propaganda poster issued by Nazi Germany. Does this mean that Commons accepts images produced by the German government as public domain? – Howardcorn33 (💬) 15:56, 17 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

Please differentiate between:
  • The German government between 1918 and 1933 (the classical Weimarer Republik);
  • The German government up to the 8th May 1945;
  • The government of the German Democratic Republic between 1949 and 1990;
  • And the government after 1949 belonging to the German Federal Republic.
For the latter, the interpretation of the inclusion of "only including legal texts (legislation, decrees, ordinances, court rulings, etc.), not photographs or artworks" is correct (a case could be argued for stamps from the Bundespost before its privatisation), for the others, one would have to consult the older law texts. Regards, Grand-Duc (talk) 16:07, 17 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
The keep votes and closing statements in the aforementioned deletion discussions don't appear to have made the distinction when applying the PD-GermanGov template to a 1942 poster. Is that erroneous? – Howardcorn33 (💬) 16:12, 17 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
Probably yes. The Urheberrechtsgesetz, the copyright law of the federal republic should have continued the protection of works still protected, but, as it was incepted post-war, I find it hard to apply it to something from 1942. Nazi Germany also had a copyright law, but I do not know whether it provided for PD statutes. Regards, Grand-Duc (talk) 16:30, 17 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
I think you are correct that {{PD-GermanGov}} should not apply here, for the reasons plainly stated in the template itself. If the authorship of the image was attributable to the German government, however, I think it might be free in Germany as {{PD-Germany-§134-KUG}} (since the government is a legal person under public law) and also free of COM:URAA issues in the US under the Alien Property Custodian exception (since any URAA-restored copyright would have been restored to the German government).
However, KUG § 9 (at least in the 1907 version) specifies that Ist auf einem Werke der Name eines Urhebers angegeben oder durch kenntliche Zeichen ausgedrückt, so wird vermutet, daß dieser der Urheber des Werkes sei. ("If an author's name is indicated on a work or expressed [on the work] through distinctive marks, this author is presumed to be the author of the work.") So unless there's some evidence to the contrary, I think we have to assume that G. Peiler was the author and retained the copyright. Nailing down the German copyright term would require confirming exactly who this Peiler was and when he died -- but assuming this is correctly labeled as a 1941 work, it would at any rate not be free in the US until 2037.
From COM:POLAND it seems to me that the same would apply if this was considered a Polish work, as was suggested in one of the discussions. Since it is not a photograph, {{PD-Poland}} would not apply. -- Visviva (talk) 20:21, 17 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
  • I found an explicit statement that this file is in the public domain and I have added the following text to the licencing informations:
This site run by the United States National Library of Medicine asserts that this poster is in the public domain.
I think that we can assume that a US Government Department has employed lawyers before making this statement, so unless anybody in this discussion who has a qualification in law can argue to the contrary, I think that Wikimedia is safe in assuming that it can host this image without infringing copyright.
Martinvl (talk) 21:20, 17 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
One does.not need to be trained in copyright law to see an area of tension with an official site policy Wikimedia Commons only accepts media [...] that are in the public domain in at least the United States and in the source country of the work. So, a US government department is likely to check for US rights, but also unlikely to check for foreign protection. And given that Nazis were unlikely to comply with US ©️ formalities and some intellectual property was confiscated in the aftermath of WW2, a statement that a work originating in the Germany from 1941-1942 is in the PD is both likely true for the US and thus legally permissible to save on Wikimedia's servers. But it can still be a violation of our own rules (the Kunsturhebergesetz enacted in 1907, the precursor to the current copyright law, may have a provision that would deny protection for official propaganda works, though). But researching that on small touchscreen Android devices is a pain (I'd need my PC, but I can't access it at the moment. If nobody else jumps in, I'll try to learn something as soon as possible). Regards, Grand-Duc (talk) 22:01, 17 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
I mean, that's certainly not a US government statement. It's just PubMed's copy of an article published by Cambridge University Press (which also contained the same statement, probably relying on the cited source of "Biblioteka Jagiellońska, 804981 V, T.3/61(4)" or perhaps on the same source link we provide, which also says that but does not provide the institution's reasoning). I don't think we can necessarily take a third party's claims of public domain status at face value, especially when no reasoning is provided. -- Visviva (talk) 04:03, 18 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
The determination on another website probably just looked at U.S. law, where given this would have been a German-government-owned copyright, would mean the URAA would not get involved (and there is no copyright notice on the poster), so the U.S. situation seems fine. At worst, this can go to en-wiki rather than being deleted. Given the fuzziness of the old Germany law, it could get complicated. However, the poster is in Polish, and was primarily distributed in Poland, from the sounds of it. That means it was likely simultaneously published in (at least) Poland and Germany. For "country of origin", you would pick the countries among those with the shortest term. Given that there is about nothing known about the named artist, despite this being a pretty well-known poster and I'm sure subject to a fair amount of research, it could well be a pseudonym. Regardless, seems like we could use Polish laws -- which at this point I think are standard EU laws. If we assume that is a pseudonym, that could be {{PD-anon-70-EU}}. It does seem to be OK in the U.S., and I do think we should use Polish laws and not German most likely. It would be a German-government-owned copyright, with Poland as the most likely country of origin, but with a term associated with "G. Peiler". But, it may make sense to treat that as pseudonymous. I do agree that PD-GermanGov should not apply. Carl Lindberg (talk) 17:54, 18 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

Opinion, please, on this tranche of uploads

[edit]

Please see this editor's uploads, where I am unsure whether these may be uploaded at all, and doubly unsure about the GIMP XCF items.

Please will an expert have a look, offering advice to the uploader where necessary?

Asking here seems a better route than my starting a DR simply based on my uncertainty. 🇵🇸‍🇺🇦 Timtrent 🇺🇦 talk to me 🇺🇦‍🇵🇸 14:16, 18 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

Portugal has FoP, but this photos likely conflicting with normal exploration of the work per {{FoP-Portugal}}. I am unsure about photos itself. Evelino Ucelo (talk) 19:46, 18 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
@Evelino Ucelo Thank you. What I want to try to avoid is a DR with no acceptable rationale. This would upset the uploader with no justification. 🇵🇸‍🇺🇦 Timtrent 🇺🇦 talk to me 🇺🇦‍🇵🇸 19:57, 18 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

Presumably unpublished picture from the 1930s

[edit]

Gentle Wikimedians:—

I was notified that a picture I recently found and uploaded may be deleted due to unclear copyright status. It is a photograph in the University of Sydney Archives, taken in the late 1930s and presumably unpublished. The Archives website confirms it is public domain in Australia, so is it not also out of copyright in the USA and other jurisdictions? Here is the photo in question.

Thanks in advance - KnightofFaerië (talk) 19:52, 18 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

Since the author is not known and it was published after 2002, the image will remain under copyright protection in USA for 120 years from its creation date. Ruslik (talk) 20:26, 18 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
But this photo potentially can be work for hire, if so then the university can license it under a free license. Evelino Ucelo (talk) 23:56, 18 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
If it's unpublished then it is unfortunately unsuitable for Commons until probably about 2060 (absent a free license from the copyright holder as suggested above). However, that sure looks like the kind of photo that would have been taken for the purpose of some sort of university publication. It seems odd that the only online publications for this period are the student newspaper and yearbooks of the law and medical faculties. Surely there would have been other publications from other parts of the university, or the university as a whole, that might have included this photo. Perhaps the university archives might have some publications that aren't currently online? -- Visviva (talk) 01:19, 19 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
That seems rather unlikely to be unpublished, at least by U.S. definitions. How did it get in the Archives in the first place, and when? Sounds like prints were given to the archives, and this was a series of such photos. That act (if not something that happened before) was almost certainly publication. Seems like a formal portrait, but may have been a faculty photo or something like that -- but somehow the archives ended up with a copy. Likely that act, or something which happened before, qualified as U.S. publication. To me, that question is a theoretical doubt, and not a significant doubt requiring deletion.
When uploaded, it had the PD-Australia tag, which seems accurate. But it also had the {{Remove this line and insert a license instead}} tag, which is what will get files marked for deletion -- it was tagged as no-license when there was a license. So, that shouldn't have been there, given there was a valid license tag also present. I think that is PD-Australia and PD-1996. Given the speedy tag was erroneous (no-license when there was one, mistaken due to the presence of that other tag upon upload), I removed the speedy. If someone wants to nominate for deletion over the highly theoretical question on when it was published by the tortured U.S. definitions of the time, they can do that. Carl Lindberg (talk) 22:28, 19 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
Thank you @Clindberg and also @Visviva! I did contact the University, and an archivist responded that it was found with the note "Sydney Morning Herald 2/11/38". Unfortunately I find it quite difficult to search in that newspaper in Trove, but it seems to be an indication that it was published. — KnightofFaerië (talk) 15:24, 23 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

File:Hong Kong - Himitsu sentai Gorenger sticker.jpg

[edit]

File:Hong Kong - Himitsu sentai Gorenger sticker.jpg is photo of a sticker. If I understand correctly, no valid reason why it is in the public domain. Evelino Ucelo (talk) 23:42, 18 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

I think that is correct, per COM:FOP Hong Kong: freedom given in Sect 71 does not apply to posters or maps in public places. The same would likely apply to File:Stickers (7231200664).jpg and the other files extracted from it. -- Visviva (talk) 01:22, 19 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

Request for independent review of file licensing

[edit]

I'd appreciate input from uninvolved editors regarding the copyright status of the following file:

File:Godzilla, King of the Monsters! (1956) - trailer.webm

Wikipedia user Armegon and I disagree over whether this file qualifies as free content under Commons' licensing requirements. Rather than continuing the disagreement, I would like for it to be established whether either of our interpretations of the relevent licensing policies is correct.

Here is the relevant discussion.

Could uninvolved editors please help access the copyright evidence and explain which policies apply? I'm open to correction if I have misunderstood anything. TalkTuahLunchly (talk) 03:29, 20 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

As an uninvolved editor, it seems to me that the file is correctly tagged {{PD-US-no-notice}} and {{Free depiction (PD)}}. The trailer was published in the US before 1978, and assuming that it was distributed without a copyright notice (as I would expect), it is therefore public domain. Of course that has no effect on the copyright status of any part of the movie not included in the trailer. There are some similar but more recent examples given in COM:FREEDEPICTION, where a movie or game is copyrighted but the trailer is released under a free license. However, perhaps there is some nuance here that I am missing. -- Visviva (talk) 03:57, 20 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
Maybe let Armegon know? TalkTuahLunchly (talk) 04:01, 20 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
Both Visviva and Armegon have pretty good points. TalkTuahLunchly (talk) 17:08, 20 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
Keep the debate going so we can come to a conclusion. TalkTuahLunchly (talk) 19:41, 20 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

My main issue is that alot of fans upload images and videos to Wiki Commons and slap the public domain tag as if that makes them untouchable and no one's the wiser. As a result, no one properly vets the copyright status of these uploads. This is more concerning for the Godzilla franchise. Toho, the owners of the franchise, are as litigious as Disney and protect their IP with a legal iron fist. Another issue I have is that copyrights can be renewed, and the English versions of Godzilla films (and their press materials) have exchanged ownership over the years; that's one reason why the American version of Godzilla 1985 still hasn't received an official DVD, Blu-ray, or 4K UHD anywhere, due to copyright issues in Japan and overseas. So yeah, that's my issue: whether these images/videos are truly public domain. Armegon (talk) 06:30, 20 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

If the video is what it appears and purports to be, then it was (1) published, (2) before 1978, (3) in the United States, (4) with the copyright owner's authorization, and (5) without a copyright notice. If all of those things are correct, then it is in the public domain under US law. See COM:HIRTLE for a summary. In this case, the trailer entered the public domain immediately upon publication, as a result of failure to comply with copyright formalities. (This was typical for trailers at the time.) Because there was never a copyright, renewal does not come into the picture. As far as I can see, the only way for such a publication to stop being in the public domain, would be for someone to persuade a court (or Congress) to change the existing, settled law.
If the video is somehow not what it purports to be -- if it's actually a recent hoax, for example -- then it most likely would not be in the public domain. I will admit I am not enough of a film scholar to judge whether that could be a possibility. But to take that suspicion seriously, I think there would need to be some articulable basis for it. -- Visviva (talk) 01:35, 21 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

Category:Gameplay of Tetris - follow-up

[edit]

Following off of some recent discussions about images in this category (1 and 2), I've added a description to the category page:

English: This category is for images that illustrate the game mechanics of Tetris. Note that although game mechanics are ineligible for copyright, the specific "look and feel" of Tetris has been held to be copyrighted (see Tetris Holding, LLC v. Xio Interactive, Inc.). As such, images in this category that are substantially similar to the visual expression of the original Tetris video game may be nominated for deletion.

Feel free to make edits to the language on the category page as well as add a message box template, translations, etc. Qzekrom (talk) 06:48, 20 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

Relatedly, I would like to push back against proposals to delete every image in this category. As suggested by Pere prlpz, it is certainly possible to illustrate the game mechanics without reproducing the copyrightable expression specific to OG Tetris; such images should not be nominated for deletion. I might also suggest that we rename the category to something like "Tetris game mechanics" to avoid confusion - ideally, images in this category depict the mechanics of Tetris, not Tetris itself. Qzekrom (talk) 06:54, 20 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
[edit]

Hi! I found some works from North Korea here: https://www.loc.gov/resource/asian.80640093-1961-01-01-01/?sp=4&r=-0.023,-0.031,1.132,0.855,0. The LOC claims there are no copyright restrictions. Template:PD-North Korea claims DPRK works are protected 50 years after publication, when the creator is an organisation. Would we be safe for works until 1975? Thanks in advance! --PantheraLeo1359531 😺 (talk) 08:14, 20 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

Addendum: https://blogs.loc.gov/international-collections/2020/05/now-online-north-korean-serials-digitization-collection-at-the-library-of-congress/ --PantheraLeo1359531 😺 (talk) 08:24, 20 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
Per {{PD-North Korea}} and North Korea's relevant URAA restoration date of 28 April 2003, work published in NK after 1953 received an URAA copyright extension in the US and hence any images of works published in NK after 1953 are not permitted on Commons. – Howardcorn33 (💬) 16:47, 20 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
This means that only works which were public domain in NK on 28 April 2003 are permitted on Commons, otherwise receiving the URAA extension. – Howardcorn33 (💬) 16:48, 20 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
That would be true if NK's 2001 copyright law retroactively granted copyright to works published before its enactment. The statute is vague in some places - this blog post suggests that it was largely enacted for performative reasons: [1] Qzekrom (talk) 17:34, 20 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
So in the worst case, any works BEFORE 1953 are safe on Commons? --PantheraLeo1359531 😺 (talk) 06:51, 21 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
Commons goes off of what is de jure permitted in the copyright law, not if it is de facto unenforced by authorities. – Howardcorn33 (💬) 06:55, 21 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
I was suggesting that works created before 2001 might have never gotten de jure copyright protection in NK, depending on whether the North Korean copyright act was applied retroactively to older works or only to works created after the act - in which case they would not get URAA copyright in the USA either. De facto enforcement has nothing to do with it. Qzekrom (talk) 07:04, 21 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
I see. That interpretation would be good news for our purposes, but we would need to be sure that the act didn't apply retroactively. – Howardcorn33 (💬) 07:14, 21 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
This would be indeed important to investigate. The Internet Archive for example has some old works of the Pyongyang times and potentially more old works :) --PantheraLeo1359531 😺 (talk) 14:30, 21 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

Clothing without people

[edit]

If clothing is worn by a person it is definitely a utilitarian object. But what about something like File:Vidal v. Elster.jpg. I think that may need to have permition sent to COM:VRT or am I overreacting? ℺ Gone Postal (〠 ✉ • ✍ ⏿) 08:47, 20 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

Irrelevant in this case, since the photo of the t-shirt is not an original work of the uploader (eg. same photo was posted here with a grey background in 6 June 2023). – Howardcorn33 (💬) 16:41, 20 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
Even if the photo wasn't stolen, I think your opinion is correct. The illustration on the shirt is the central focus of the work and is subject to copyright protection. Based5290 :3 (talk) 19:38, 20 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
Thanks, I have nominated all three images of that t-shirt for deletion. I would like it to be kept if we can, but I think it is very likely that even if the designer is the uploader, then they may have been a "one-upload account". ℺ Gone Postal (〠 ✉ • ✍ ⏿) 04:50, 21 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

River flowing into salar de Uyuni.jpg

[edit]

file:River flowing into salar de Uyuni.jpg: dubious "own work" claim, but perhaps it falls under {{PD-USGov-NASA}}? It is satellite photo from Sentinel-2. Evelino Ucelo (talk) 15:18, 20 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

I think the correct license is {{Attribution-Copernicus}}? Based5290 :3 (talk) 21:55, 20 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

Sophia Kingdom Brunel

[edit]

Is it reasonable to use this picture of Sophia Kingdom Brunel (Isambard's mother) on Commons without seeking permission? It surely must be public domain by now. Marnanel (talk) 19:20, 21 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

It's probably okay, but I would get in contact with the museum and ask for information about the picture (when it was made, the provenance of it, etc). I remember a previous case where a painting was assumed to be made during the lifetime of the subject in the 1800s, but it turned out the painting was actually made in the 1960s. Based5290 :3 (talk) 20:22, 21 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
The article notes that:

Whilst Marc was in America, he would occasionally write to Sophia, in one letter including a miniature painting of her from memory, along with one of him. In her widowhood she wore these in a locket, though the letters that accompanied them are gone. It is one of very few pictures of her.

In my opinion, this is most likely referring to the same painting included as an image in the article, which would date it to 1790s (when Marc Brunel was staying in the US). – Howardcorn33 (💬) 06:00, 22 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

US Ambassador portrait

[edit]

Sorry if this is a stupid question, but US embassies can't hold copyright, correct? It's my understanding that embassies can't hold copyright because they operate under the State Department, so {{PD-USGov-DOS}} applies. I'm asking because I uploaded File:Chargé d’Affaires at the U.S. Embassy in Nicaragua, Elias Baumann.jpg and noticed afterwards that the metadata said the image was copyrighted and reuse wasn't permitted. I thought that I might have missed a copyright notice on the source page (I didn't), but then I noticed that the metadata also said the copyright holder was "© 2026 United States Embassy, Nicaragua". I think this is just a fluke but if not I'll tag the file with {{Db-author}}. Streetr4 (talk) 02:16, 22 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

I would also be inclined to think it is most likely simply an error. However, it is possible that the photo was taken by someone other than a US government employee, and that person then transferred the copyright to the embassy. That is provided for in 105(a) of the Copyright Act: the United States Government is not precluded from receiving and holding copyrights transferred to it by assignment, bequest, or otherwise. The State Dept website also cautions that photos are not public domain [i]f copyright is indicated. So unfortunately I think deletion is probably most consistent with COM:PRP.-- Visviva (talk) 04:47, 22 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
Works by the US govt are known to be public domain in the United States itself, however, the United States government itself asserts that such works do enjoy copyright protection in foreign countries. It is therefore possible the assertion of copyright on this file is valid outside the United States. – Howardcorn33 (💬) 05:53, 22 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
I've requested deletion based on the replies here. This is more of a Wikipedia question, but would this image be allowed on English Wikipedia with {{PD-USonly}} in that case? Streetr4 (talk) 13:33, 22 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
It would be acceptable in Commons if that template applied, I think. On Commons, public domain content has to be public domain in both the source country and the US. The source country for US govt works is already the US so if its public domain in that country, it's acceptable on Commons anyway. – Howardcorn33 (💬) 18:33, 22 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
[edit]

Hello, I would like advice before uploading a scan of a Kuwaiti nationality certificate issued to Abdullah Mudhaf Abdullah Al-Mudhaf on 5 July 1960.

His family provided the scan. The certificate includes a portrait whose photographer is unknown. The same certificate was published by Al Rai newspaper on 31 December 2012: https://www.alraimedia.com/article/371809

Does the exemption for official administrative texts in Kuwait cover this certificate? How should the embedded portrait and US copyright status be assessed? Is there an appropriate Commons licensing tag, or should I refrain from uploading it?

I do not claim to own the photographer’s copyright. Thank you. MARIAMALMUDHAF (talk) 06:15, 22 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

Copyright status in Kuwait is clear as it was issued in 1960 and hence is public domain per {{PD-Kuwait}}. US copyright status would be uncertain, in my opinion. If it received copyright protection in the US in the first place, the US copyright would have been extended by URAA as it was still copyrighted in Kuwait in 1996. Nevertheless, it is presently disputed on Commons whether US copyright laws protect passport photos per COM:PASSPORT. The text is probably fine per {{PD-text}} as passports tend to display biographical data in an unstylized format. – Howardcorn33 (💬) 18:54, 22 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
Thank you for clarifying. If I redact the portrait and upload only the certificate’s text and biographical details, would that be acceptable on Commons? If so, which licensing tags should I use? MARIAMALMUDHAF (talk) 19:12, 22 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
If you redact the portrait, then the templates {{PD-Kuwait}} and {{PD-text}} should suffice. – Howardcorn33 (💬) 19:15, 22 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
[edit]

Hello, could someone please help verify the correct UK copyright tag for this book? Title:Portuguese Possessions in India Author:Great Britain. Foreign Office. Historical Section Publication year:1920 Publisher: H.M. Stationery Office Source: https://www.loc.gov/item/a22000936/ Wikimedia Commons file: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Portuguese_Possessions_in_India.pdf

I have added {{PD-US-expired}} for US public-domain status. I would like to confirm the appropriate UK copyright tag for this historical government publication before finalising the licensing section.

Thank you. ArBay11 (talk) 18:21, 22 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

{{PD-US-expired}} is the US copyright tag for the work, which although still needed for Commons, is not relevant for UK copyright status. The publication is nevertheless still public domain in the UK per {{PD-UKGov}}, so you should add that template to the licensing section next to the US template. – Howardcorn33 (💬) 18:35, 22 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
THANK YOU ArBay11 (talk) 18:45, 22 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
[edit]

Hello, I would appreciate help determining the copyright status of this scanned document.

Title: The Konkan Cultural Association Constitution, Memorandum and Articles of Association

File: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:The_Konkan_Cultural_Association_Constitution,_Memorandum_and_Articles_of_Association.pdf

I personally scanned this document from a physical copy. I have examined all the pages, but I could not find a publication date, an individual author's name, or a copyright notice. I also searched online but could not find another copy or reliable publication information.

The document concerns the Konkan Cultural Association. I do not want to guess its publication date or apply an incorrect public-domain licence.

Could someone advise me on how to establish its copyright status and whether any suitable Wikimedia Commons licence or public-domain tag applies?

Thank you for your help. ArBay11 (talk) 18:29, 22 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

Photos in Category:Claude Harris

[edit]

I recently created Category:Claude Harris to organize images but I fear most may be non-free: the English photographer Claude Harris died in 1961 (less than 70 years ago), and all of the images appear to originate from the UK, so {{PD-old-70}} does not apply, although some were republished by Bain News services (e.g. File:Sir Rider Haggard LCCN2014713840.jpg and File:Actress LCCN2014718634.jpg) while at least one is released by the Wellcome Library under CC-BY-4.0. Some of the images are in wide use across Wiki projects, so I wanted to open discussion before initiating a batch deletion nomination, to determine which images may be valid, and which should be deleted until 2031. Does "Bain-washing" make UK images acceptable? --Animalparty (talk) 00:09, 23 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

Like many organisations marking images as in the public domain, the LoC's "No known restrictions" will usually only cover US copyright; the LoC does not seem to make any statement that they have ever obtained any copyright themselves and are now placing it in the public domain. Indeed, even on the Wellcome Collection's catalogue entry page I can't seem to find the claimed CC license (although I haven't checked archived versions of the page). Felix QW (talk) 14:06, 23 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

Public domain status of "Sin Chung Kuo Weekly" series files

[edit]

Hello! I found the files in Category:新中國周報 except File:NLC404-01JF2376-1874 新中國周報 1938年第一期.pdf might be marked with Chinese public domain works wrongly. These were a series of Batavian (now Jakarta) weekly newspaper written in Traditional Chinese characters. Considering them published between 1947-1948 in Indonesia, I think these files should be applied with {{PD-IDOld-Art58}}. However, I was not familiar with Indonesian law and history. Need some advise if that template is proper for those files. Thank you!

tntchn Comment · Contribs 03:28, 23 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

As these are not photographs, it seems likely that these may still be in copyright at least in the US; if published 1947-8 in Indonesia, they will have been in copyright there on January 1st 1996 [as the copyright term there seems to be at the shortest publication + 50 years] and therefore should likely be copyrighted in the US until 95 years after publication. Felix QW (talk) 14:11, 23 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

Community-contributed subtitles of CC BY YouTube videos

[edit]

I just came across TimedText:COMEDY.webm.vi.srt, which seems to have been copied verbatim from the corresponding one on YouTube. COM:YOUTUBE doesn't say anything about subtitles. Are these subtitles fine or should they be deleted? NguoiDungKhongDinhDanh 18:22, 23 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

Generally only the copyright holder can apply a CC license on their work, and the license doesn't apply to work they do not own. When the YouTube channel owner applies the CC license, it would only apply to their creation (i.e. the video itself).
For the subtitles of this case, although the subtitles are a derivative work of the video, it is creative and original enough that it would be above TOO. This means it would have its own separated copyright, which it would be owned collectively by those who contributed to it.
Since the video creator is not the copyright owner of this subtitle file, therefore it cannot apply the CC license to the subtitles file, hence I think this subtitle file should be deleted. However, other users here are welcomed to create their own subtitles for the video. Thanks. Tvpuppy (talk) 23:28, 23 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International

[edit]

is it ok to upload photos under https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/ in wikimedia? Pouyasg (talk) 22:43, 23 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

@Pouyasg, "non-commercial" licenses are not allowed on Wikimedia Commons, as all files in Commons must be allowed for commercial use. Please see Commons:Licensing for more details, particularly the Forbidden licenses section. Thanks. Tvpuppy (talk) 23:07, 23 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

File:대구광역시 Daegu.jpg

[edit]

Hello. Can anyone check on the licensing status of this file. I don't have full confidence on the "own work" claim of @Ocbb0404: , considering that they uploaded a couple of questionable files in the past (see User talk:Ocbb0404). I need a third opinion on this because the reverse image searches on TinEye and Google Lens did not register prior hits. JWilz12345 (Talk|Contributions) 03:23, 24 October 2026 (UTC)Reply